For the last two years, I have had a baby in my care at the end of the year, and it is one of the things that brings me the most joy in the holiday season. Christmas lights and JJ Heller’s Christmas album and decorating trees inside the house and the additional community of friends and family… I consider it a miracle every time I get to be the first one to introduce a baby to these wonderful things.
But for every joyous feeling I have, there is also a shadow. Because it should be my babies’ birth moms who get to introduce these things. They should be the ones who get to wake up smiling every day as they choose yet another cute outfit for their child to wear or plan ways to celebrate the holiday with their little one or quietly sing Christmas carols in the middle of the night when the baby wakes up hungry.
But it isn’t their birth mom who gets to spend time doing this, it’s me. So I try to document everything with pictures and share them every chance I get with their birth parents, whether in person during a visit or through a text. But it’s not the same. I see it in the grief these parents carry with them at the end of every visit as they have to face the reality yet again that they are going home while their baby stays behind.
For every moment of wonder and happiness I get to experience, there is an equal amount of grief because this is not the way it is supposed to be. Every smile I see on my baby’s face is a smile their mom is missing out on, and that is not a truth I can carry lightly.
And while I know all foster parents struggle to carry both sides of this story, we are also surrounded by well-intentioned people who share their opinions.
“Those babies are so lucky to have you – now you know they’re safe since you give them such a loving and caring home.”
“I can’t believe you have to still meet with the birth parents! Why should you have to take time out of your day when they’ve already proven they can’t parent their kids?”
“Why do their parents even bother? You know they aren’t going to get their kids back – they should just be happy they’re in a better place now.”
“It must be so nice to have a baby for the holidays! All the cute outfits and fun things you can do – you must be so happy!”
I hear these things all the time, and I can’t help but wonder how people can be so happy for me and yet care so little for my babies’ birth parents. What about them? Do you think they are so happy they don’t have to get up in the middle of the night to feed their baby that they don’t feel the gaping hole in their hearts that is the absence of their child? Do you think they are just relieved and go about their lives like nothing has changed since before they found out they were pregnant?
I am confounded that so many people seem to be outraged about whatever trauma my babies have have been exposed to but don’t seem to consider the trauma the birth parents must have experienced to have gotten to this point. Trauma is generational and the same things will continue to happen throughout generations of families unless someone steps in to intervene and break the cycle.
The birth parents I know experience loss, deep hurt, and betrayal from people long before they had children that had to go into foster care. They did not wake up one day, with a great life that included family who cared, a good support system, and healthy models of coping, and decide to go a different route.
For the birth parents who are using substances, most of them started in their teens or younger – where is the outrage on their behalf for that exposure? For the birth parents who are in a domestic violence situation, most of them saw the same kind of relationship with their parents or where abused physically or emotionally as a child – where is the outrage on their behalf for the violence they experienced? For the birth parents who just don’t seem to take care of their baby, most of them don’t have parents they can ask for baby advice or friends they talk through all the challenges of raising a child – where is the outrage for the lack of healthy people in their life?
I don’t want to shame anyone for trying to make nice comments about what I do as a foster parent. But these comments all too often see the value of the little babies and remove all value from their parents, and I just cannot accept this.
In this Christmas season, where we look forward to celebrating how God came in the form of a tiny helpless baby to be Immanuel, God With Us, it seems short sighted to think that God came down to be with just me and my babies but not their birth parents.
If Christmas is truly a time of hope become reality, of light coming into the darkness of the world, of goodwill to all mankind, then this should be just as true for the birth parents as it is for my babies. So this Christmas season, may we all look forward to the possible redemption of all peoples, not just the people we like or deem blameless. May we all answer the invitation to follow Jesus as he is Redeemer, Light of the World, Wonderful Counselor, and Immanuel.
We are not called to save anyone – only Jesus can do that. But we should also not be stumbling blocks to anyone, and I think that includes being a stumbling block to birth parents who are doing their best get their children back. I invite you this season to join with me in recognizing both sides of the foster care story, mine and the birth parents’. And feel free to celebrate with me as I get to enjoy another Christmas with a tiny human, but may those good feelings never come at the cost of dehumanizing their first parents.